Question: Is it Sunnah or obligatory to recite quietly in the silent prayers (Salah) and aloud in the audible prayers? If a woman has continuously recited silently in audible prayers, what should she do now? Additionally, how loud should a woman recite during audible prayers – is it sufficient for her to hear herself?
Answer: It is Sunnah for both men and women to recite quietly in the silent prayers (Salah) and aloud in the audible prayers. We must perform the prayers as the Prophet (ﷺ) taught us, following all its prescribed forms. The question of what is obligatory and what is Sunnah should not be the focus; rather, we should perform the prayer with all its pillars, obligations, and Sunnah acts, as the Prophet (ﷺ) said: “Pray as you have seen me praying.” (Sahih al-Bukhari: 6008, 7246, 631).
If a woman has continuously recited silently in all her prayers, she has only neglected the Sunnah, but her prayers are still valid. There is no issue with what has happened in the past, but from now on, she should differentiate between silent and audible prayers. If she is in a place where non-mahram men are present, she may recite the audible prayers silently due to necessity. However, if no non-mahram men are present, she should recite aloud, and it is sufficient for her voice to be loud enough for her to hear herself, meaning there should be a sound, not just a mental recitation.
Sheikh Maqbool Ahmed Salafi حفظه الله ⟨Jeddah Dawah Center, Hayy Al-Salamah, Saudi Arabia⟩
Islamic fatwa on permissible intimacy during Haiz and Nifas, prohibition of intercourse before Ghusl, and Kaffarah for violations. Backed by… Read More
Clarifying Islamic rulings: If menstruation starts before Iftar, the fast is invalid and must be made up. Learn the wisdom… Read More
Explore the authenticity of viral sayings like "Remain chaste, your women will remain chaste" and "Zina is a debt." This… Read More
Discover how forgiveness in Islam, guided by the Quran and Hadiths, can heal your heart and bring peace to your… Read More
Delve into Sharia's prohibition of matam, wailing during calamities, watching mourning processions, and facts about Aisha (RA)'s actions, supported by… Read More
Understand Islamic guidelines on exchanging Salaam between non-mahram men and women, backed by Quran, Hadith, and scholars like Ibn Uthaymeen,… Read More