Topics: Manners

Vigilante Justice: Is Extorting Money from a Driver for Damages Justifiable?

The Ethics of Self-Imposed Fines: A Case Study

Question: A truck passing through the village broke the power lines, and the villagers surrounded the driver and demanded 20,000 rupees, eventually settling for 9,000 rupees. However, repairing the lines only cost 1,000 rupees. Was this action justifiable, and was it permissible to take the extra money?

Answer: If the police were notified, then this became a police matter, and they should have handled it according to the law. However, if the villagers decided to handle it themselves, they should have called an electrician to repair the lines and charged the driver for the actual repair costs. Extorting an excessive amount of money from the driver is unjust and constitutes oppression.

Respondent: Sheikh Maqbool Ahmed Salafi Hafizahullah 

Jeddah Dawah Center, Saudi Arabia  

Interpreter: Hasan Fuzail

Author: IslamicHelper

IslamicHelper

Recent Articles

Beware: Shaytan’s Seven Traps to Misguide You

Discover the seven cunning traps Shaytan uses to lead believers astray, as explained by Imam Ibn al-Qayyim. Learn how to… Read More

7 days ago

The Truth About “Inni Mutawaffika”: Jesus’ Ascension in Islam

Explore the true meaning of "Inni Mutawaffika" in the Quran regarding Jesus (AS). This article refutes misconceptions and establishes the… Read More

7 days ago

Nikah in Islam: A Complete Guide

Discover the sacred institution of Nikah in Islam, its significance, conditions, and how to build a blessed marriage according to… Read More

7 days ago

Zakah in Quran and Sunnah: A Complete Guide

Explore the fundamental pillar of Islam, Zakah, through authentic references from the Quran and Sunnah. Learn its significance, calculation, and… Read More

3 weeks ago

Great Inventors of the Islamic Golden Age

Discover the remarkable inventors of the Islamic Golden Age who revolutionized science, medicine, and technology. From algebra to optics, their… Read More

3 weeks ago

Healthy Eating in Islam: Sunnah Foods & Principles

Discover the timeless wisdom of Islamic healthy eating. Learn about Sunnah foods, their benefits, and how to incorporate them into… Read More

3 weeks ago