Question: Twelve years ago, two brothers jointly purchased a plot. The elder brother told the younger brother to register the plot in his name, as they lived together in one house. The money for the plot came from the elder brother’s wife, who was known to the family. A few years later, the younger brother installed a borewell at the elder brother’s house, and the elder brother said he couldn’t repay the debt, so he told the younger brother to take the borewell money from the plot. Two years later, the younger brother sold the plot without informing the elder brother and told him afterward. He hasn’t disclosed the sale price yet. A few days later, the elder brother’s wife suggested selling their plot to repay their debt, at which point the elder brother revealed that the younger brother had sold it two months earlier without informing them. Is this action permissible according to Sharia?
Answer: The elder brother made a significant mistake by telling the younger brother to register the plot in his name. He should have included his name in the land registry since the plot belonged to both brothers. If the elder brother’s name was on the registry, the younger brother couldn’t have sold the entire plot. The elder brother’s second mistake was suggesting that the younger brother take the borewell money from the plot, implying that the plot should be sold. How else could he get his money without selling the plot? When the elder brother learned about the sale two months earlier, he should have informed his wife. This indicates that he also made a significant mistake in this matter.
In any case, since the plot was jointly owned by both brothers, the younger brother should have sold it with the elder brother’s consent. If he made a mistake by selling it, he should at least now disclose the correct sale price and return the elder brother’s money. The money given to the younger brother by the elder brother is considered the elder brother’s money, even if it came from his wife.
Sheikh Maqbool Ahmed Salafi حفظه الله ❪Jeddah Dawah Center, Hayy Al-Salamah – Saudi Arabia❫
Is performing a second congregational prayer (Jam'at-e-Thani) in the mosque after the first one allowed? Detailed analysis with authentic Hadith… Read More
A detailed analysis proving that the famous quote attributed to Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal — “Can a believer love Yazid?”… Read More
A detailed examination of classical Shia scholarly consensus on the alteration (Tahrif) of the Quran, backed by quotes from major… Read More
In an age of rising blasphemy against the Prophet ﷺ, studying his Seerah is not just recommended but essential. This… Read More
Is it necessary to treat children equally when giving gifts (Hibah) in Islam? Can parents give more to a son… Read More
A detailed compilation exposing Salman Nadwi’s alleged disrespectful remarks against noble Sahaba like Muawiyah, Abu Hurairah, and others, from an… Read More