Question: What is the ruling on reading the translation of the Quran by Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanvi, and can his other books be read? Is it necessary to follow an Imam?
Answer: Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanvi was a Deobandi scholar, and every Deobandi is a follower (Muqallid), even if they are a scholar. This means that being a scholar does not benefit a Muqallid, as they follow the sayings of an Imam.
There are issues with Ashraf Ali Thanvi’s beliefs. He was an advocate and practitioner of Sufism, and he even wrote a book on it. It should be noted that Sufism is considered ignorance and irreligion.
If you pick up just one of Ashraf Ali Thanvi’s books, “Bahishti Zewar,” you will see how much filth, impurity, and Shariah-opposing content is written in it.
My advice to you is not to study Ashraf Ali Thanvi’s “Bayan-ul-Quran” or his other books. Every moment of life is precious, and it should be spent in acquiring correct knowledge. Alhamdulillah, there are so many Tafsirs (exegeses) of the Salafi methodology that you will not be able to read all of them in your lifetime. So why waste time on non-Salafi Tafsirs that contain incorrect beliefs along with their thoughts and ideologies?
You also asked whether it is necessary to follow an Imam. The answer is that following an Imam is not a requirement in Islam. Allah revealed the Quran to Muhammad (peace be upon him), and this Quran is our religion, which was sent down from the heavens. Muhammad (peace be upon him) preached this Quran. This Quran is our constitution of life, so we will not follow any Imam but will obey and follow Allah and His Messenger. Allah has commanded in numerous places in the Quran to obey Allah and His Messenger. The only person whose example we are to follow is Muhammad (peace be upon him). No other scholar besides Muhammad (peace be upon him) is an example for us.
Sheikh Maqbool Ahmed Salafi حفظه الله ❪Jeddah Dawah Center – Al-Salamah – Kingdom of Saudi Arabia❫
Explore the historical Ahl-e-Sunnah perspective on Yazid bin Muawiyah. Discover why prominent Sahaba, Ahl-e-Bayt, and scholars chose silence over rebellion. Read More
Is performing a second congregational prayer (Jam'at-e-Thani) in the mosque after the first one allowed? Detailed analysis with authentic Hadith… Read More
A detailed analysis proving that the famous quote attributed to Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal — “Can a believer love Yazid?”… Read More
A detailed examination of classical Shia scholarly consensus on the alteration (Tahrif) of the Quran, backed by quotes from major… Read More
In an age of rising blasphemy against the Prophet ﷺ, studying his Seerah is not just recommended but essential. This… Read More
Is it necessary to treat children equally when giving gifts (Hibah) in Islam? Can parents give more to a son… Read More