Question: If we are teaching in a school and some of the children come from poor families, can we give the school fees collected to these poor children, knowing that the school is government-run? Occasionally, teachers impose fines on students to prevent them from taking leave. If those fines are sometimes spent on personal matters, would that be sinful?
Answer: There are several aspects to consider in response to your question.
1. The first point is that if it is a government school and the government has not imposed any fees for education or for students taking leave, then it is not permissible for a teacher to collect any such fees from the children that the government has not imposed.
2. The second point is that, in light of Sharia, it is not permissible to impose financial penalties on anyone. Therefore, the financial penalties collected from students who take leave in schools and madrasas are not permissible according to Sharia.
3. The third point is that where the government has imposed fees for a specific purpose, the teacher can only collect those fees, and since that fee is a trust from the government, it is necessary to deposit it into the government treasury; it should not be spent on personal matters or for the children.
In summary, it is not permissible to collect financial penalties from school students or to collect fees on one’s own accord to give to poor children. If a teacher wishes to help a poor child, they should do so from their own pocket and funds. If a teacher spends such money on personal matters, they would be sinful.
✍ Sheikh Maqbool Ahmad Salafi, may Allah preserve him
❪Jeddah Dawah Center – Al-Salamah – Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
Is performing a second congregational prayer (Jam'at-e-Thani) in the mosque after the first one allowed? Detailed analysis with authentic Hadith… Read More
A detailed analysis proving that the famous quote attributed to Imam Ahmad bin Hanbal — “Can a believer love Yazid?”… Read More
A detailed examination of classical Shia scholarly consensus on the alteration (Tahrif) of the Quran, backed by quotes from major… Read More
In an age of rising blasphemy against the Prophet ﷺ, studying his Seerah is not just recommended but essential. This… Read More
Is it necessary to treat children equally when giving gifts (Hibah) in Islam? Can parents give more to a son… Read More
A detailed compilation exposing Salman Nadwi’s alleged disrespectful remarks against noble Sahaba like Muawiyah, Abu Hurairah, and others, from an… Read More