Question: If morning and evening adhkar (remembrances) are recited in a group, is it correct to play videos from YouTube for the adhkar that need to be recited 100 times and follow along?
Answer: Morning and evening adhkar should be recited individually by each person; it is not a collective act to be done in a group. Therefore, if a few women recite the morning and evening adhkar together in a group, it is considered an innovation (bid’ah). Listening to adhkar on YouTube does not count as performing the adhkar. For adhkar, it is necessary to recite them yourself, moving your tongue. Listening to a video is not sufficient, but if you recite along with the video, there is no harm. However, if you have to recite the adhkar yourself, there is no need to play the video.
✍ Answer by: Sheikh Maqbool Ahmed Salafi, Jeddah Dawah Center, Saudi Arabia
The Gathering (Hashr) and Resurrection (Ba'th) on the Day of Judgment "The Righteous Answers to Wise Questions" — (Part 17)… Read More
In Part 16 of “The Righteous Answers to Wise Questions,” Allamah Zaid al-Madkhali explains the various abodes of souls in… Read More
In Part 15 of “The Righteous Answers to Wise Questions,” Allamah Zaid al-Madkhali details the major scenes of Qiyamah —… Read More
In this part of “The Righteous Answers to Wise Questions,” Allamah Zaid al-Madkhali explains the most virtuous gatherings — sitting… Read More
Who Can Skip Fasting in Ramadan: Qada and Fidyah Explained Question: For which people is it permissible to skip fasting?… Read More
In Islam, suicide is strictly forbidden (Haram) even to protect honor, as life belongs to Allah. A woman forced into… Read More